Fairfax Aspire wants Epsom and Ewell council to pay its full appeal costs over 110 homes at Langley Vale. The inspector's written decision has no date yet.

The developer behind plans for 110 homes at Langley Vale wants Epsom and Ewell Borough Council to pay its full costs of the appeal. Fairfax Aspire Ltd filed an updated costs application on 18 November, after the public inquiry at Epsom Town Hall finished hearing evidence.

Both sides’ closing speeches and the costs claim are now in the council’s inquiry documents library. The inspector, Joanna Bowyer, will decide the appeal in writing. No decision date has been published.

Overview

  • The site: Farm View, Langley Vale Road, about 5.2 hectares of farmland. Outline plans for up to 110 homes, half of them affordable.
  • The one real dispute: whether the site is a “sustainable location”. The council accepts it is grey belt and that the borough badly needs homes.
  • The council’s ask: dismiss the appeal.
  • The developer’s ask: allow it, and make the council pay its costs.
  • What next: a written decision from the inspector, on a date not yet set.

The argument has narrowed to one question

The council refused the scheme in March on four grounds. By the end of the inquiry, its closing submissions, dated 13 November, accepted a good deal of the developer’s case.

The council now accepts:

  • the site is grey belt land
  • there is evidenced unmet housing need
  • building on it would not “fundamentally undermine” the purposes of the Green Belt across the borough
  • the horse racing reason for refusal no longer stands, subject to suitable conditions

What it still disputes is whether people living there could reasonably get about without a car. The council argues they could not, “even after the proposed transport measures”. If the site fails that test, the homes count as inappropriate development in the Green Belt.

The developer’s closing submissions call this a “decision tree” that turns on a single point. It says all parties agree that if the site passes the sustainable-location test, permission should be granted.

The bus money is at the centre of it

The draft legal agreement offers £200,000 a year for five years towards buses. The money would go either to a more frequent E5 service or to an extended demand-responsive service.

In its written closing, by barrister Sophia Spencer, the council argued that choosing the demand-responsive option does not secure a better E5. It also said “housing is permanent”, and that five years of funding does not show the service would carry on.

The developer says the current E5 reaches Epsom in 15 minutes and that “the issue is service frequency”. It says the council’s own transport witness accepted the bus improvements would be a “significant benefit” to people already living in Langley Vale. It also says the five-year funding period was what Surrey County Council’s passenger transport team asked for.

Why the developer wants its costs paid

The updated costs application, signed by Richard Turney KC, seeks a full award. Its main points:

  • council officers recommended approval in February, and their advice was “reviewed and concurred with by Counsel”
  • inspectors found the neighbouring Langley Bottom Farm site to be a sustainable location in 2022 and 2025
  • councillors gave no clear reason for departing from that
  • the council accepted at the inquiry that landscape was not a reason for refusal in its own right

The application also complains that the council did not file its closing submissions on 13 November, the day they were due. It says there was “a national email outage”, but no request for more time on the day and no apology.

A costs award does not decide the appeal itself. It decides whether the council pays the developer’s appeal costs, which would come from the council’s budget.

The numbers behind the case

The developer’s closing puts the borough’s housing position plainly. Epsom and Ewell can show only a 1.6 year supply of housing land, a shortfall of 3,402 homes over five years. It says 1,541 households are on the housing register, and that 55 of them could have a home at Farm View.

The Langley Vale Action Group took part as a full party, with its own barrister and witnesses. Its closing submissions were not in the council’s library on 20 November.

What it means for you

  • Nothing changes on the ground yet. No homes can be built unless the inspector allows the appeal.
  • The papers are public. Every closing speech, the costs claim and the evidence are in the council’s Farm View appeal library.
  • The decision is final at this level. It is the inspector’s to make, not councillors’. It can only be challenged in the High Court on a point of law.
  • A costs award would fall on the council. Any payment would come out of the same budget that pays for council services.

Our report from the opening day sets out the timetable and the full draft legal agreement, including the 50% affordable housing and the £1 million for buses.