Councillors unanimously approved repairs to the empty Bourne Hall lodge in Ewell and its reuse as a social home on 5 November. Listed building consent was also granted.
The empty lodge at the gates of Bourne Hall in Ewell is to be repaired and let as a social home. The Planning Committee approved both applications unanimously on Thursday 5 November.
Updated 12 November: the draft minutes of the 5 November meeting show the committee unanimously granted planning permission for 26/00879/FUL. Permission is subject to conditions and a Statement of Intent securing the building’s use as social housing. No members of the public registered to speak. The committee also unanimously granted listed building consent.
Updated 7 November: the council’s planning register shows listed building consent (26/00880/LBA) as “Application Permitted”, with the decision issued on 5 November. That covers the repairs to the lodge, the gates, the lantern and the griffin statue. The planning application for the social home itself, 26/00879/FUL, still showed “Awaiting decision” on 7 November. The council has not yet published the meeting’s minutes.
Officers recommend approval. The committee report describes the lodge as an early 19th-century house that originally served as the entrance lodge to Bourne Hall’s gardens. It is Grade II listed and currently vacant.
What would be done
The plans, under references 26/00879/FUL and 26/00880/LBA, include:
- new timber double-glazed windows made to match the old ones
- replacement of the doors that are not period, and fire upgrades to the historic ones
- a new boiler and extractor vents for the kitchen and bathroom
- a paved courtyard and new gutters and downpipes
- repairs to the iron entrance gates and lantern, taken off site for about two weeks
- specialist repair to the griffin statue over the south entrance gate
The lodge has three rooms on each floor, with two double bedrooms upstairs. The report gives its floor area as 79 square metres, enough for a two-bedroom home for four people, with a garden to the west. There is no parking.
The heritage row
The council’s own conservation officer opposes parts of the scheme. The report records a “strong objection” to replacing the Regency sash windows, which still have original crown glass. The officer also objects to removing the staircase and the lath and plaster ceilings.
The applicant team says some windows are “rotten beyond salvage”. It says the staircase is too steep to meet building regulations and that the ceilings risk “total collapse”.
Planning officers accept there would be “a modest degree of harm”. They say the benefits outweigh it: the building comes back into use rather than falling into disrepair, and it provides social housing. A condition would require more investigation of which original features can be saved, before work starts.
The council cannot sign a legal agreement with itself. So the social housing use would be secured by a “statement of intent” instead.
Why it is going to committee
No one objected. Notices went to 16 neighbouring properties, and no comments came back from residents or the ward councillors.
It goes to committee because the council owns the building. It is also one of the first cases under the new national planning rules that take effect today, 31 October. The report says the council’s nominated officer and nominated member agreed to send it to councillors rather than let officers decide. Our explainer on the new rules sets out what has changed.
What it means for you
- The meeting was public. The Planning Committee met at 7.30pm on Thursday 5 November in the Council Chamber at Epsom Town Hall, and the recording is on the council’s YouTube channel. The agenda and papers are online.
- Expect the gates to be off for a fortnight once work starts. The report says temporary fencing would stand in for them while they are repaired.
- The council’s housing waiting list has over 1,450 households, according to its Local Plan report. One lodge will not dent that, but it is a home that has stood empty.
For other applications near you, see our Epsom planning news page.
Have your say